I realize that I’m only 19 years old, and sometimes it probably seems ridiculous that I make some of the statements that I do, because how could I possibly have the knowledge or experience of one to talk about politics, spirituality, truth, or life? If your stance on my blog, in the past, has been one of skepticism or doubt, criticism or judgment, you might want to pass on reading this one, or perhaps you would like to pick a fight with me, I don’t know. But I am going to talk about war. Yeah, war.
First of all, I will say that I strongly believe God hates war. People often point to the Old Testament in saying what a just war is, in the manner that God used war, the amount of times He used war to accomplish His will, and such claims. Now, I think most of you might agree with this, that God hates war, and I think most of you will agree that war is an evil thing, and is only necessary because of the fall.
(I pause, briefly, because I realize we are in a battle against Satan, “Against the rulers, against the powers, against the world forces of this darkness, against the spiritual forces of wickedness in the heavenly places.” We are, as Paul says in Ephesians, in a war against Satan and his spiritual allies. Now, let us notice that we are not in a war against “flesh and blood,” as Paul states prior to the listing of what we actually are at war with.)
In Hosea, a beautiful book and story, God’s anger and love for Israel swings back and forth between punishment and redemption. In chapter 2, as God explains how He will restore Israel, He says, “I will abolish the bow, the sword, and war from the land, and will make them lie down in safety.” God’s plan for restoration does not, at all, include war. I think you know this, dear reader.
One: I do not agree with the so-called “War on Terror” we are waging in Iraq. (I think most of us have (hopefully) reached this point.) What are we fighting?
Two: I do not agree with the war in Afghanistan. After convincing from my smart friend in DC, I have come to oppose this war also, a war which many people still support/like, or whatever. I think that the search for bin Laden is just provoking our enemies in the Middle East and simply multiplying the problem. Here is an article that talks about the surge of al-Qaeda related groups: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=11173538 (It’s from NPR which rocks.)
Three: I am terrified, and would strongly oppose a war with or in Pakistan.
Four: I am flirting with pacifism.
Here are a few quotes from Letters from Abu Ghraib, by Josh Casteel:
“Freedom is not made by pipelines being bought in Afghanistan, nor by the major private corporations handling construction and oil distributions (Enron, Halliburton) who profit incredibly by the joint military venture/tax breaks set forth by the Bush Administration. Freedom is nor made behind closed doors with Saudi regimes (who espouse the very same Wahabist Sunni ideas as the terrorists) because we fear losing their input in the American economy (which is over 7%). My contention with George Bush is not one of believing him malevolent, but rather believing him unwise and guilty of maligning God’s freedom with mere political rhetoric.”
“Capital Hill has replaced the Vatican, and hospitals and political parties have replaced the Church as “new salvation,” granting “life” and “freedom” to those who follow their teaching. We don’t need the Eucharist, we have medicine. Democracy is now forced upon peoples like Christianity was during the Holy Roman Empire, in the “Christianizing” of civilization—now, we’re “Democratizing,” and instead of the Pope or an Emperor, we have the American President.”
“You can’t call [President Bush] “Pro-Life” . . . Campaigning in the name of Life and Family in circumstances such as these, to my mind, is simply unconscionable. And if I could sit down with the commander in chief right now, and talk things through, I too would simply say “shame on you, Mr. Bush.” How dare you take up the sword Peter was told to lay down, and use it in the name of a freedom which cannot be won by force . . . Where’s al-Qaeda? Where’s bin Laden? Where is the investigation into the nation from which all of the 9-11 hijackers were natural-born citizens (Saudi Arabia)?”
Point being: I am learning, and forming my opinions, and right now I strongly oppose every war we are in. I hate war. If you have ever been to a war-torn country, you hate war too. If you haven’t, go.
What is with our obsession of violence?
4 comments:
Dear Mrs. Potter: I, like you, have not spent a whole lot of time thinking through the morality of war. A Catholic theologian named Richard Benson has written a book talking about the three major Catholic positions on what's known as "Just War Theory." If you are interested in the field, I would pick it up and give it a look.
To your point: Of course God hates war. The only question then becomes, does God hate things more than war? I don't know the answer to that question - perhaps Benson would shed some light.
Secondly, if it is the case that our actions in Afghanistan provokes Islamo-fascists, then, judging by the record of terrorism since 2001 inside U.S. borders, it also must be true that war-provoked Islamo-fascists are fairly impotent. Ignoring the Islamo-fascist problem in the decades prior to 2001 doesn't seem so effective these days.
Finally, Josh Casteel may be an expert on what went on inside Abu Ghraib, but when he plays the global blame game, his accusations sound more conspiratorial than thoughtful. Identifying Enron as a beneficiary or cause of the Afghanistan invasion is silly: Enron couldn't have benefitted - the organization went belly up just after the war began. His info appears to come not from inside knowledge, but from dubious conspiratorial bloggers at Common Dreams.
Post script: Why did you erase my previous comments?
"The only question then becomes, does God hate things more than war?"
-I don't really know where this fits in.
"It also must be true that war-provoked Islamo-fascists are fairly impotent."
-It is true that there haven't been attacks on our soil since 9-11. That is a good point. But I look to the future: for example, in 1991, when we entered the Persian Gulf, we began to devour the middle east, and I believe 9-11 was a consequence of that. Point being: you reap what you sow, and I fear what the last 7 years will reap.
"Josh Casteel may be an expert on what went on inside Abu Ghraib, but when he plays the global blame game, his accusations sound more conspiratorial than thoughtful."
-I find it absurd that you would say that. Josh was on the front lines of American foreign policy, and to suggest his thoughts as "conspiratorial" is ridiculous. I find every statement he makes regarding the war more informed than anything else I have heard about it. He was actually there, where have you obtained your information?
Caffeine and Irony: It's funny to me that you haven't told me who you are. If I know you, tell me. If I don't, please do continue the brilliant comments. And I deleted the last comments because they were completely off-topic and, to be blunt, quite ignorant of my education and beliefs. I will continue to delete your comments unless you tell me who you are.
John Dawson, if this is you, you know me better than the comments you have left! The ones on the last post were ridiculous! Of course I don't believe Heaven is some tree-hugger's Heaven!
And please don't make remarks like that about Josh Casteel, he is an awesome guy and has been on the front lines. It offends me that you would say that.
Please tell me you are plying Devil's Advocate . . . because I know you are smarter than the comments you have left.
"Unity and self-sacrifice, of themselves, even when fostered by the most noble means, produce a facility for hating. Even when men league themselves mightily together to promote tolerance and peace on earth, they are likely to be violently intolerant toward those not of a like mind."
-Eric Hoffer
1951
Post a Comment